The login flow now falls back to OAuth client credentials flow when the admin PAT token is not available. This allows login.html to work even when Zitadel PAT generation hasn't been configured yet. - Added get_oauth_token() helper function - Login now tries PAT first, then OAuth client credentials - Includes proper Zitadel scope for API access 🤖 Generated with [Claude Code](https://claude.com/claude-code) Co-Authored-By: Claude <noreply@anthropic.com>
22 KiB
VibeCode Complete Implementation Roadmap
Executive Summary
Current Status: BotUI's backend is 80% complete with powerful LLM-driven code generation. The frontend needs professional tools to match Claude Code's capabilities.
What Works (Backend):
- ✅ LLM-powered app generation (AppGenerator: 3400+ lines)
- ✅ Multi-agent pipeline (Orchestrator: Plan → Build → Review → Deploy → Monitor)
- ✅ Real-time WebSocket progress
- ✅ Database schema generation
- ✅ File generation (HTML, CSS, JS, BAS)
- ✅ Designer AI (runtime modifications with undo/redo)
- ✅ chromiumoxide dependency ready for browser automation
What's Missing (Frontend):
- ❌ Monaco/CodeMirror editor (just textarea now)
- ❌ Database UI (no schema visualizer)
- ❌ Git operations UI
- ❌ Browser automation engine (using Rust + chromiumoxide)
- ❌ Multi-file editing workspace
- ❌ Enhanced terminal
Architecture
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ USER REQUEST │
│ "I want a full CRM system" │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ VIBE BUILDER UI │
│ - Agent cards (Mantis #1-4) │
│ - Task nodes visualization │
│ - WebSocket real-time updates │
│ - Live chat overlay │
│ - Code editor (Monaco) ← Phase 1 │
│ - Browser automation panel ← Phase 4 │
│ - Database schema visualizer ← Phase 2 │
│ - Git operations UI ← Phase 3 │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ BOTSERVER (Rust Backend) │
│ ┌────────────┐ ┌────────────┐ ┌────────────┐ │
│ │ Orchestrator│ │AppGenerator│ │Designer AI │ │
│ │ (5 agents) │ │(LLM-driven)│ │(modifications)│ │
│ └────────────┘ └────────────┘ └────────────┘ │
│ ┌────────────┐ ┌────────────┐ ┌────────────┐ │
│ │ Browser │ │ Git │ │ Terminal │ │
│ │ Automation │ │ Operations │ │ Service │ │
│ │(chromiumoxide)│ │(git2) │ │(xterm.js) │ │
│ └────────────┘ └────────────┘ └────────────┘ │
└────────────────────────┬────────────────────────────────────┘
│
▼
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ GENERATED OUTPUT │
│ - PostgreSQL tables │
│ - HTML pages with HTMX │
│ - CSS styling │
│ - JavaScript │
│ - BASIC tools/schedulers │
│ - E2E tests (Playwright) │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘
Implementation Phases
Phase 1: Code Editor Integration (P0 - Critical)
Goal: Replace textarea with professional code editor
Tasks:
-
Download Monaco Editor
cd botui npm install monaco-editor@0.45.0 cp -r node_modules/monaco-editor min/vs ui/suite/js/vendor/ -
Create Editor Component
botui/ui/suite/partials/editor.html- Monaco container with tab bar
- File tree sidebar
- Save/Publish buttons
-
Editor JavaScript
botui/ui/suite/js/editor.js- Monaco initialization
- Language detection (.html, .css, .js, .bas, .json)
- Tab management (open, close, switch)
- Auto-save with WebSocket sync
-
API Endpoints
botserver/src/api/editor.rs- GET
/api/editor/file/{path}- Read file - POST
/api/editor/file/{path}- Save file - GET
/api/editor/files- List files
-
Integration
- Update
chat-agent-mode.html- replace textarea with Monaco - Update
vibe.html- add editor panel - Add keyboard shortcuts (Ctrl+S, Ctrl+P, Ctrl+Shift+F)
- Update
Success Criteria:
- Monaco loads in < 2 seconds
- Syntax highlighting for 5+ languages
- Multi-file tabs work
- Auto-save completes successfully
Estimated Effort: 8-12 hours
Phase 2: Database UI & Schema Visualization (P0 - Critical)
Goal: Visual database management and query builder
Tasks:
-
Schema Visualizer Component
botui/ui/suite/partials/database.html- Canvas-based ER diagram
- Table cards with fields
- Relationship lines (foreign keys)
- Zoom/pan controls
-
Database JavaScript
botui/ui/suite/js/database.js- Fetch schema:
/api/database/schema - Render tables using Canvas API
- Click table → show field details
- Drag to rearrange
-
Query Builder UI
- Visual SELECT builder
- Table selection dropdown
- Join interface
- Filter conditions
- SQL preview pane
-
Data Grid
- Sortable columns
- Inline editing
- Pagination
- Export (CSV/JSON)
-
Backend API
botserver/src/api/database.rs- GET
/api/database/schema- Tables, fields, relationships - GET
/api/database/table/{name}/data- Paginated data - POST
/api/database/query- Execute SQL - POST
/api/database/table/{name}/row- Insert/update - DELETE
/api/database/table/{name}/row/{id}- Delete
Success Criteria:
- ER diagram shows all tables
- Query builder generates valid SQL
- Data grid supports inline edits
- Export works correctly
Estimated Effort: 16-20 hours
Phase 3: Git Operations UI (P1 - High Priority)
Goal: Version control interface in Vibe
Tasks:
-
Git Status Panel
botui/ui/suite/partials/git-status.html- File list with status icons
- Stage/unstage checkboxes
- "Commit" button
-
Diff Viewer
botui/ui/suite/partials/git-diff.html- Side-by-side comparison
- Line highlighting (green/red)
- Syntax highlighting
-
Commit Interface
- Message input
- "Commit & Push" button
- Progress indicator
-
Branch Manager
- Branch dropdown
- "New Branch" dialog
- Switch/delete actions
-
Commit Timeline
- Vertical timeline
- Author, date, message
- Click → view diff
-
Backend API
botserver/src/api/git.rs- GET
/api/git/status- Git status - GET
/api/git/diff/{file}- File diff - POST
/api/git/commit- Create commit - POST
/api/git/push- Push to remote - GET
/api/git/branches- List branches - POST
/api/git/branch/{name}- Create/switch - GET
/api/git/log- Commit history
Success Criteria:
- Git status displays correctly
- Diff viewer shows side-by-side
- Commit workflow works end-to-end
- Branch switching succeeds
Estimated Effort: 12-16 hours
Phase 4: Browser Automation Engine (P1 - High Priority)
Goal: Pure Rust browser automation for testing & recording
Why Rust + Chromiumoxide:
- ✅ Already in workspace:
chromiumoxide = "0.7" - ✅ No Node.js dependency
- ✅ Feature flag exists:
browserin botserver/Cargo.toml - ✅ Reference implementation: bottest/src/web/browser.rs (1000+ lines)
Tasks:
-
Core Browser Module
botserver/src/browser/mod.rsBrowserSession- Manage browser instanceBrowserManager- Session lifecycle- Methods:
navigate(),click(),fill(),screenshot(),execute()
pub struct BrowserSession { id: String, browser: Arc<chromiumoxide::Browser>, page: Arc<Mutex<chromiumoxide::Page>>, created_at: DateTime<Utc>, } impl BrowserSession { pub async fn new(headless: bool) -> Result<Self>; pub async fn navigate(&self, url: &str) -> Result<()>; pub async fn click(&self, selector: &str) -> Result<()>; pub async fn fill(&self, selector: &str, text: &str) -> Result<()>; pub async fn screenshot(&self) -> Result<Vec<u8>>; pub async fn execute(&self, script: &str) -> Result<Value>; } -
Action Recorder
botserver/src/browser/recorder.rsRecordedAction- Navigate, Click, Fill, Wait, AssertActionRecorder- Record/stop/export- Export as Playwright test
#[derive(Serialize, Deserialize)] pub struct RecordedAction { pub timestamp: i64, pub action_type: ActionType, pub selector: Option<String>, pub value: Option<String>, } impl ActionRecorder { pub fn start(&mut self); pub fn stop(&mut self) -> Vec<RecordedAction>; pub fn export_test_script(&self) -> String; } -
Test Validator
botserver/src/browser/validator.rs- Check for flaky selectors
- Validate wait conditions
- Suggest improvements via Designer AI
-
Browser API
botserver/src/browser/api.rs- POST
/api/browser/session- Create session - POST
/api/browser/session/:id/execute- Run action - GET
/api/browser/session/:id/screenshot- Capture - POST
/api/browser/session/:id/record/start- Start recording - POST
/api/browser/session/:id/record/stop- Stop & get actions - GET
/api/browser/session/:id/record/export- Export test
- POST
-
Vibe UI - Browser Panel
-
botui/ui/suite/partials/browser-controls.html- URL bar with navigation buttons
- Record/Stop/Export buttons
- Actions timeline
- Browser preview iframe
- Screenshot gallery
-
botui/ui/suite/js/browser.jslet currentSessionId = null; let isRecording = false; let recordedActions = []; async function initBrowser() { const resp = await fetch('/api/browser/session', { method: 'POST', body: JSON.stringify({ headless: false }) }); currentSessionId = (await resp.json()).id; } async function browserNavigate(url) { if (isRecording) { recordedActions.push({ type: 'navigate', value: url, timestamp: Date.now() }); } await executeAction('navigate', { url }); } async function browserClick(selector) { if (isRecording) { recordedActions.push({ type: 'click', selector: selector, timestamp: Date.now() }); } await executeAction('click', { selector }); } async function exportTest() { const resp = await fetch(`/api/browser/session/${currentSessionId}/record/export`); const data = await resp.json(); // Download test file const blob = new Blob([data.script], { type: 'text/javascript' }); const a = document.createElement('a'); a.href = URL.createObjectURL(blob); a.download = `test-${Date.now()}.spec.js`; a.click(); } -
botui/ui/suite/css/browser.css- Browser panel styling
- Recording indicator animation
- Actions timeline
- Screenshot gallery grid
-
-
Integration with Vibe
- Add "Browser Automation" button to Vibe toolbar
- Load browser-controls.html in panel
- Element picker for selector capture
- Screenshot capture & gallery
Usage Example:
// In Vibe UI
openBrowserPanel();
toggleRecording(); // Start recording
browserNavigate('http://localhost:3000/my-crm');
browserClick('#create-btn');
browserFill('#name', 'Test');
browserClick('#save-btn');
toggleRecording(); // Stop recording
exportTest(); // Download test-123.spec.js
Generated Test Output:
import { test, expect } from '@playwright/test';
test('Recorded test', async ({ page }) => {
await page.goto('http://localhost:3000/my-crm');
await page.click('#create-btn');
await page.fill('#name', 'Test');
await page.click('#save-btn');
});
Success Criteria:
- Can navigate to any URL
- Element picker captures selectors
- Recording generates valid Playwright tests
- Screenshots capture correctly
Estimated Effort: 20-24 hours
Phase 5: Multi-File Editing Workspace (P2 - Medium Priority)
Goal: Professional multi-file editing
Tasks:
-
Tab Management
- File tabs with close buttons
- Active tab highlighting
- Tab overflow scrolling
- Drag to reorder
-
Split-Pane Layout
- Split horizontal/vertical buttons
- Resize handles
- 2x2 grid max
-
File Comparison
- Side-by-side diff
- Line-by-line navigation
- Copy changes (L→R)
-
File Tree Sidebar
- Nested folders
- File type icons
- Expand/collapse
- Double-click to open
-
Quick Open
- Ctrl+P → Search files
- Fuzzy matching
- Arrow navigation
-
Project Search
- Ctrl+Shift+F → Search all files
- Results with line numbers
- Click to open file
Success Criteria:
- 10+ files open in tabs
- Split view works (2-4 panes)
- File comparison displays diffs
- Quick open searches files
Estimated Effort: 12-16 hours
Phase 6: Enhanced Terminal (P2 - Medium Priority)
Goal: Interactive shell in Vibe
Tasks:
-
Terminal Container
- xterm.js integration (already vendor file)
- Multiple terminal tabs
- Fit addon for auto-resize
-
WebSocket Terminal
- Bi-directional WebSocket:
/ws/terminal/{session_id} - Protocol:
{"type": "input", "data": "command\n"} - Handle ANSI escape codes
- Bi-directional WebSocket:
-
Command History
- Up/Down arrows
- Ctrl+R search
- Persist in localStorage
-
Command Completion
- Tab completion
- File path completion
- Command flags
-
Backend Terminal Server
- Spawn PTY per session
- WebSocket handler
- Clean up on disconnect
-
File Transfer
- Drag file to upload
upload/downloadcommands- Progress bars
Success Criteria:
- Can type commands & see output
- Arrow keys navigate history
- Can run vim, top, etc.
- Multiple terminals work
Estimated Effort: 10-14 hours
Phase 7: Advanced CRM Templates (P2 - Medium Priority)
Goal: Pre-built CRM accelerators
Tasks:
-
Template System
botserver/src/templates/crm/- Template JSON definitions
- Prompt templates
- Field libraries
-
CRM Templates
-
Sales CRM
- Tables: contacts, leads, opportunities, accounts, activities
- Pages: dashboard, pipeline, contacts list
- Tools: lead_scoring, email_automation
- Schedulers: daily_summary, weekly_review
-
Real Estate CRM
- Tables: properties, clients, showings, offers
- Pages: property gallery, client portal
- Tools: mls_sync, showing_scheduler
- Schedulers: showing_reminders, market_update
-
Healthcare CRM
- Tables: patients, appointments, treatments, insurance
- Pages: patient portal, appointment scheduler
- Tools: insurance_verification, appointment_reminders
- Schedulers: daily_appointments, insurance_alerts
-
-
Template Gallery UI
botui/ui/suite/partials/template-gallery.html- Template cards with descriptions
- Preview screenshots
- "Use Template" button
-
Template Generator
- Load template JSON
- Customize with user details
- Generate all files
- Deploy to /apps/{name}
Success Criteria:
- Can select template from gallery
- Template generates full CRM
- Customization works
- Generated CRM is functional
Estimated Effort: 20-24 hours
Technical Implementation Notes
Code Quality Standards (per AGENTS.md)
MUST Follow:
- ✅ Error Handling - NO panics, use
?operator - ✅ Safe Commands - Use
SafeCommandwrapper - ✅ Error Sanitization - Use
ErrorSanitizer - ✅ SQL Safety - Use
sql_guard - ✅ Rate Limiting - Per-IP and per-User limits
- ✅ CSRF Protection - CSRF tokens on state-changing endpoints
- ✅ Security Headers - CSP, HSTS, X-Frame-Options, etc.
- ✅ No CDNs - All assets local
- ✅ File Size - Max 450 lines per file
- ✅ Clippy Clean - 0 warnings, no
#[allow()]
File Organization
Botui (Frontend):
botui/ui/suite/
partials/
editor.html
database.html
git-status.html
git-diff.html
browser-controls.html
terminal.html
template-gallery.html
js/
editor.js
database.js
git.js
browser.js
terminal.js
templates.js
css/
editor.css
database.css
git.css
browser.css
terminal.css
templates.css
Botserver (Backend):
botserver/src/
api/
editor.rs
database.rs
git.rs
browser/
mod.rs # BrowserSession, BrowserManager
recorder.rs # ActionRecorder
validator.rs # TestValidator
api.rs # HTTP endpoints
test_generator.rs
templates/
crm/
sales.json
real_estate.json
healthcare.json
mod.rs
Dependencies
Already in Workspace:
chromiumoxide = "0.7" # Browser automation
tokio = "1.41" # Async runtime
axum = "0.7" # HTTP framework
diesel = "2.1" # Database
git2 = "0.18" # Git operations (add if needed)
Frontend (download & serve locally):
monaco-editor@0.45.0 # Code editor
xterm.js@5.3.0 # Terminal (already vendor file)
Testing Strategy
Unit Tests
- All new modules need unit tests
- Test coverage > 80%
- Location:
botserver/src/<module>/tests.rs
Integration Tests
- End-to-end workflows
- Location:
bottest/tests/integration/
E2E Tests
- Use chromiumoxide (bottest infrastructure)
- Location:
bottest/tests/e2e/ - Test scenarios:
- Generate CRM from template
- Edit in Monaco editor
- View database schema
- Create git commit
- Record browser test
Rollout Plan
Milestone 1: Core Editor (Week 1)
- Phase 1 complete (Monaco integration)
Milestone 2: Database & Git (Week 2)
- Phase 2 complete (Database UI)
- Phase 3 complete (Git Operations)
Milestone 3: Browser & Workspace (Week 3)
- Phase 4 complete (Browser Automation)
- Phase 5 complete (Multi-File Editing)
Milestone 4: Terminal & Templates (Week 4)
- Phase 6 complete (Enhanced Terminal)
- Phase 7 complete (CRM Templates)
Success Metrics
Phase 1: Code Editor
- Monaco loads < 2 seconds
- 5+ syntax highlighters work
- Multi-file tabs functional
- Auto-save succeeds
Phase 2: Database UI
- Schema visualizer displays all tables
- Query builder generates valid SQL
- Data grid supports inline edits
- Export functionality works
Phase 3: Git Operations
- Git status shows changed files
- Diff viewer shows side-by-side
- Commit workflow works
- Branch switching succeeds
Phase 4: Browser Automation
- Can navigate to any URL
- Element picker captures selectors
- Recording generates valid tests
- Screenshots capture correctly
Phase 5: Multi-File Workspace
- 10+ files open in tabs
- Split view supports 2-4 panes
- File comparison works
- Project search is fast (< 1s for 100 files)
Phase 6: Terminal
- Interactive shell works
- Can run vim, top, etc.
- Multiple terminals run simultaneously
- File transfer works
Phase 7: CRM Templates
- 3+ CRM templates available
- Generation takes < 30 seconds
- Generated CRMs are fully functional
- Industry-specific features work
Conclusion
The BotUI platform already has a powerful backend capable of generating full applications via LLM. The main gaps are in the frontend user experience.
Once these 7 phases are complete, VibeCode will match or exceed Claude Code's capabilities while offering:
✅ Multi-user SaaS deployment ✅ Visual app building (Vibe Builder) ✅ Enterprise-grade multi-agent orchestration ✅ Pure Rust backend (no Node.js dependency) ✅ Integrated browser automation (chromiumoxide) ✅ Professional development environment
The biggest advantage: VibeCode can already generate working CRMs via the LLM pipeline. These phases add the professional UI tools to make it a complete development environment.
Total Estimated Effort: 98-126 hours (~3-4 weeks with 1 developer)